Is your company aware of how your hiring process affects your candidates?
Janell interviewed for the perfect job three times. The hiring manager loved her. The last step was a courtesy approval from the VP.
That was in mid-June. Janell followed up regularly as she should, persistent but not a pest. After about six weeks the hiring manager stopped responding.. Finally eight weeks after her final interview Janell noticed the job was reposted with a different title.
Evidently Janell was not getting a job offer although no one told the candidate.
After analyzing the two postings, it seemed the new posting asks for an additional certification that Janell does not have.
Janell’s experience raises some important questions about the hiring process:
- Why did it take eight weeks to make a decision?
- Why didn’t anyone get back to the candidate?
- Why did the qualifications change when the job was reposted?
- Why didn’t the organization know what they wanted before they started interviewing three months earlier?
- How can the organization justify having the position vacant for so long? Isn’t that position important to the organization?
- What will Janell tell her friends and family about an organization that treats candidates like this? Think she is a raving fan? Will she have good things to say on social media?
- What is the impact on that organization’s brand if they treat candidates like this?
The hiring process in many organizations contains flaws like this. It takes too long. Hiring managers don’t know what they want. No one gets back to the candidates who are sitting on the edge of their chairs waiting to hear some good news. The organization’s brand takes a hit. Productivity is impacted.
You don’t have to treat candidates like this. Be aware of how your hiring process impacts candidates. Be considerate. Communicate with candidates. Know what you want. Save yourself the hassle of having positions open too long and candidates talking smack behind your back.

Don’t think about birthdays. Or your aches and pains. Or your insecurities. Think about that person inside you, the one other people cannot see. How old is that version of you?
He called her out for behavior completely acceptable from others. He refused to allow her to talk to the client in her normal role. He made life miserable for her while he sucked up to his superior.
You are invited to say a few words in support of a friend. A recommendation. You have some advanced notice. You think your friend is amazing so this should be easy. What do you do?
Maybe you need a specialized chemist to work on an important R&D project. Maybe like one of my clients, you need a sales person who is a hunter, the sales person who lives for the kill then moves on to find the next opportunity. This is not a person who loves to talk with existing clients and respond to their every need.